The 5 Best Seed Oil Free Mayos Ranked by Taste

Finding a mayonnaise without soybean oil, canola oil, or sunflower oil should not feel like a scavenger hunt. But walk into any grocery store, flip over a jar of mayo, and the first ingredient is almost always some form of seed oil. Even brands that market themselves as "healthy" or "organic" are usually just organic soybean oil whipped into an emulsion.

We decided to settle the debate the only way that matters. We bought five of the most popular seed oil free mayonnaises, put them in unmarked bowls, and tasted them blind. No brand bias. No marketing influence. Just flavor, texture, and honest reactions.

How We Tested

Five mayos, five unlabeled white bowls. Three testers who use mayo regularly — on sandwiches, in tuna salad, as a dipping base. Each tester scored every mayo on four criteria:

• Taste (does it taste like good mayo?)
• Texture (creamy? gritty? thin? thick?)
• Versatility (would you use it in everything, or only certain dishes?)
• Overall impression (would you buy it again?)

We also compared price per ounce and where you can actually find each one. A great mayo you cannot buy is not helpful.

The Rankings

1. Primal Kitchen Avocado Oil Mayo

Taste: 9/10 | Texture: 9/10 | Versatility: 9/10

This was the unanimous winner across all three testers before we even revealed the brands. The flavor is rich, tangy, and unmistakably mayo. It does not taste "healthy" or "alternative" — it just tastes like really good mayonnaise.

The texture is thick and creamy, almost identical to traditional Hellmann's. It holds up in tuna salad without making it watery. It spreads on bread without tearing. It works as a base for aioli, ranch dressing, and dipping sauces.

Made with avocado oil, organic eggs, and organic vinegar. No sugar, no seed oils, no gums or fillers.

Price: About $0.70/oz at most stores. Not cheap, but competitive for the category.

Availability: Widely available at Whole Foods, Target, Walmart, Costco (larger jar), and online through Thrive Market where it is frequently discounted.

Bottom line: This is the one we keep in our fridge. It is the mayo that converts skeptics.

2. Chosen Foods Classic Avocado Oil Mayo

Taste: 8/10 | Texture: 8/10 | Versatility: 8/10

A very close second. Chosen Foods makes a mayo that is slightly milder than Primal Kitchen — less tang, more neutral. Some testers actually preferred this in applications where you do not want the mayo to be the star (like a sandwich with lots of other flavors).

The texture is smooth and creamy but slightly thinner than Primal Kitchen. It emulsifies well and does not separate in the jar.

Made with avocado oil, cage-free eggs, and distilled vinegar.

Price: About $0.60/oz — slightly cheaper than Primal Kitchen.

Availability: Whole Foods, Costco, Target, Sprouts, and most natural grocery stores. Also on Thrive Market.

Bottom line: Excellent everyday mayo. If you prefer a milder flavor or want to save a little money, this is a great choice.

3. Sir Kensington's Avocado Oil Mayo

Taste: 7/10 | Texture: 8/10 | Versatility: 7/10

Sir Kensington's has a distinct flavor profile — slightly more savory, almost umami-forward compared to the others. One tester loved this. Two thought it was good but a little "different" from what they expected mayo to taste like.

The texture is excellent. Thick, smooth, and holds its shape well. The jar design is also notably better than the others — wide mouth, easy to scoop.

Made with avocado oil, organic eggs, organic lemon juice, and organic mustard.

Price: About $0.80/oz — the most expensive in our test.

Availability: Whole Foods, some Target locations, and online. Harder to find than Primal Kitchen or Chosen Foods.

Bottom line: Premium quality but a unique taste that is not for everyone. Try it if you like more complex flavors in your condiments.

4. Kewpie Avocado Oil Mayo

Taste: 7/10 | Texture: 7/10 | Versatility: 6/10

Kewpie is legendary in the Japanese mayo world. Their traditional version (made with soybean oil) is arguably the best-tasting mayo on the planet. The avocado oil version carries some of that Kewpie magic — rich egg flavor, slight sweetness, distinctive umami depth.

However, the texture is noticeably thinner than the others. Kewpie mayo is designed to be squeezed from a bottle, not scooped from a jar, so it has a more sauce-like consistency. This is great on rice bowls and as a drizzle but less ideal for thick sandwich spreads or tuna salad.

Also worth noting: the avocado oil version is harder to find than standard Kewpie. Check Asian grocery stores or order online.

Price: About $0.75/oz, but availability affects effective cost (shipping adds up).

Availability: Limited in mainstream grocery stores. Available on Amazon, Asian grocery stores, and specialty food sites.

Bottom line: A unique mayo experience. Worth trying if you love Kewpie's flavor, but not the best all-purpose seed oil free option.

5. Homemade Avocado Oil Mayo

Taste: 6/10 | Texture: 5/10 | Versatility: 7/10

We included homemade because many seed-oil-free advocates recommend it. The recipe is simple: egg yolks, avocado oil, lemon juice, mustard, salt. Blend until emulsified.

The honest truth? Homemade mayo is tricky. Our first batch broke (the emulsion separated). The second batch worked but had a grassy, slightly bitter aftertaste that avocado oil sometimes produces when blended at high speed. The texture was thinner than any store-bought option and it only lasted about a week in the fridge.

With practice, you can make good homemade mayo. But it takes trial and error, and the taste and texture are inconsistent batch to batch. For most people, a good store-bought option is more practical.

Price: About $0.30/oz for ingredients — the cheapest option by far.

Availability: Your kitchen. You need avocado oil, eggs, lemon, mustard, and a blender or immersion blender.

Bottom line: Fun to make occasionally, but not practical as your everyday mayo. Buy a good avocado oil mayo and save the DIY for when you want a project.

The Price Reality

Seed oil free mayo costs more. There is no way around it. Avocado oil is more expensive than soybean oil, and that cost gets passed to you. Here is the price breakdown:

| Mayo | Price/oz | 12oz Jar |

|------|----------|----------|

| Primal Kitchen | $0.70 | $8.40 |

| Chosen Foods | $0.60 | $7.20 |

| Sir Kensington's | $0.80 | $9.60 |

| Kewpie Avocado Oil | $0.75 | $9.00 |

| Homemade | $0.30 | $3.60 |

For comparison, a jar of Hellmann's is about $0.25/oz. So you are paying roughly 2-3x more for seed oil free. Whether that is worth it depends on how often you use mayo and how much you care about avoiding seed oils.

Our practical advice: buy Primal Kitchen or Chosen Foods in bulk at Costco or through Thrive Market to bring the per-ounce cost down. The Costco-sized Primal Kitchen jar drops the price significantly.

Key Takeaways

• Primal Kitchen Avocado Oil Mayo is the best overall — rich flavor, perfect texture, widely available.
• Chosen Foods is the best value — slightly milder taste but excellent quality at a lower price.
• Sir Kensington's is premium and unique — worth trying but harder to find and more expensive.
• Kewpie Avocado Oil is for Kewpie fans — thinner texture, limited availability, but distinctive flavor.
• Homemade is cheapest but inconsistent — fun as a project, impractical as a daily driver.
• Buy in bulk through Costco or Thrive Market to offset the higher cost of seed oil free options.

The seed oil free mayo market has improved dramatically in the last two years. You no longer have to choose between clean ingredients and good taste. Primal Kitchen proved that, and the competition followed.

Affiliate Disclosure: This article may contain affiliate links. If you make a purchase through these links, we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. We only recommend products we genuinely believe in. This helps support our work and allows us to continue providing free content.